Talk About Network

Google


Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


Crafts > Hvac > Hermatic vs Scr...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 1 of 19 Topic 136134 of 136382
Post > Topic >>

Hermatic vs Scroll

by essenz <john@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Jul 1, 2008 at 08:18 PM

I just picked up some new old stock Lieberts (1984 and 1990). Back
then Liebert used 3-PH Hermatic Compressors on their 30k-70k BTU size
units.

On the newer units I have, they use Scroll compressors.

I'm curious as to why?

I know scroll is supposed to be more efficient, but isn't hermatic
more reliable long-term. If the hermatic style lasts longer, but is
less efficient then scroll, how much less efficient.

I can easily swap out these NoS hermatic compressors with brand new
copeland scroll units, but I'm not sure if its worth it.

On a side note, I have a unit with a Copeland 5-ton scroll (3-PH 460V)
that has developed a significant vibration. Charge is good, sight
glass is clear, lube is good, just has a bad vibration you can really
feel on the floor up to 5-10 ft away. The comp is on rubber
insulators, and if you push it in a certain direction it goes away a
little, but not much. My technician told me not to worry or advance
replace it, just let it run, if it breaks down will fix it then. I am
concerned about performance loss, and the vibrations are annoying as
hell.

-John
 




 19 Posts in Topic:
Hermatic vs Scroll
essenz <john@[EMAIL PR  2008-07-01 20:18:28 
Re: Hermatic vs Scroll
.p.jm@[EMAIL PROTECTED]   2008-07-02 00:07:09 
Re: Hermatic vs Scroll
"KJPRO" <KJP  2008-07-01 23:41:37 
Re: Hermatic vs Scroll
"Noon-Air" <  2008-07-02 07:38:07 
Re: Hermatic vs Scroll
ftwhd <ftwhd@[EMAIL PR  2008-07-02 16:53:43 
Re: Hermatic vs Scroll
"KJPRO" <KJP  2008-07-02 17:31:09 
Re: Hermatic vs Scroll
"-zero" <som  2008-07-02 17:23:57 
Re: Hermatic vs Scroll
don <donald_vd@[EMAIL   2008-07-11 12:27:27 
Re: Hermatic vs Scroll
"Stormin Mormon"  2008-07-12 10:39:15 
Re: Hermatic vs Scroll
"Stormin Mormon"  2008-07-12 10:41:13 
Re: Hermatic vs Scroll
"DIMwit" <ig  2008-07-12 18:32:17 
Re: Hermatic vs Scroll
"Stormin Mormon"  2008-07-13 07:30:37 
Re: Hermatic vs Scroll
Robert Neville <dont@[  2008-07-13 07:49:28 
Re: Hermatic vs Scroll
Don Ocean <ocean@[EMAI  2008-07-13 16:17:37 
Re: Hermatic vs Scroll
"Zyp" <nospa  2008-07-13 16:13:29 
Re: Hermatic vs Scroll
"Stormin Mormon"  2008-07-14 08:57:08 
Re: Hermatic vs Scroll
=?ISO-8859-15?Q?Tekkie=AE  2008-07-14 21:45:10 
Re: Hermatic vs Scroll
"Stormin Mormon"  2008-07-14 23:20:39 
Re: Hermatic vs Scroll
"Bo" <noone@  2008-07-14 23:30:46 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan12V112 Sun Nov 23 5:48:06 CST 2008.